The Idea and Timeliness of Interregional Comparative Law Between Europe and Latin America
/Armin von Bogdandy & Manuel Góngora-Mera
Armin von Bogdandy is Director at the Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law.
Manuel Góngora-Mera is a Lawyer and Master of Laws in Economic Law (Pontificia Universidad Javeriana), Master in International Economics and Development Policy (Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg), and Doctor of Public Law (Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin).
Comparative constitutional law has a blind spot where much of contemporary constitutional politics is now decided: the region. Scholars mostly compare states. Even when they discuss “families” or “traditions” of law, they usually focus on a single jurisdiction, such as France for the civil law tradition, or the United States for presidentialism. Comparative work does reach toward the regional level from several directions, and it is worth being precise about how our project relates to each. Regional human rights courts have been compared directly, most comprehensively in Laurence Burgorgue-Larsen’s The 3 Regional Human Rights Courts in Context, which brings the European, Inter-American, and African courts together in a single study. This, however, compares the three courts as institutions, not regions as socially embedded constitutional orders. The EU has also been compared to individual large polities: to the United States by Cappelletti, Seccombe, and Weiler in their integration-through-law classic and by Lenaerts, as well as to India by Dann and Thiruvengadam. Finally, there is comparative work with a single regional focus on each side of our own comparison: the Max Planck Handbooks in European Public Law that one of us has co-edited, and the Oxford Handbook of Constitutional Law in Latin America that Roberto Gargarella co-edited.
The Gap
The gap lies in comparison between two regions: not their supranational institutions alone, and not a chosen representative state, but the layered phenomenon. This is what we set out to do for Europe and Latin America with a focus on their regional constitutionalisms. We see that as particularly timely as both are challenged by new political forces.
The project thus proposes comparison between regions, understood neither as an aggregation of their member states nor as a shorthand for their supranational institutions, but as an object with an autonomous constitutional profile. It accordingly requires a concept of region and regional law sturdy enough to bear comparison, yet loose enough not to overreach. In this vein, we do not treat regional law as a legal order but as a looser assemblage of norms, institutions, practices, doctrines, canonized judgments, and shared background understandings that hangs together as a recognizable unit.
Conceptual Specifications
We see three layers of this idea. At its most minimal, “European law” or “Latin American law” simply names the totality of legal phenomena within a geographic area, much as one might speak of “African law.” A second, more demanding specification ties the region to a socially and normatively defined territory: Europe as the territory of the European Union; Latin America as the as the territory of the Americas falling within the scope of the Inter-American jurisdiction and where Spanish or Portuguese are widely spoken. A third specification condenses the region through its defining features and cross-references: European law as everything connected to European integration, Union law, Council of Europe law including the European Convention on Human Rights, and the national law tied to them; Latin American law as the product of more than five centuries of legal development that articulates common structures and challenges, integrated through the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, a process one might call the “Inter-Americanization” of national law. Of course, this entails critical choices. On our third specification, “European law” leaves aside the Council of Europe states that stand outside the European Union - Iceland, the United Kingdom and Ukraine - even though they share the European Convention on Human Rights; “Latin American law” leaves aside countries such as Cuba, which falls outside the jurisdiction of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, and Barbados, which, despite being subject to that jurisdiction, does not share the Spanish- or Portuguese-speaking and Iberian legal tradition that defines the region under this specification. We see our choices justified by our research objective: regional multi-level constitutionalism.
Crucially, on any of these three specifications, the region does not collapse into its supranational institutions alone. A regional legal order, on our understanding, includes the national phenomena shaped by, and in turn shaping, the regional layer; for example, a national constitutional court’s jurisprudence that informs or reflects that of other courts. Our regional approach implies resisting the temptation to compare only the supranational layer – the Court of Justice of the European Union against the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, say – while treating the national level as mere background. That would misrepresent both regions and the very pluralism that defines them. It would miss the sites where regional constitutionalism actually becomes social reality. But taking the national level seriously means making representative statements about dozens of national legal orders. A single national example, however well chosen, cannot stand in for either region without reproducing exactly the collapse into a paradigmatic jurisdiction that we set out to avoid; a full catalogue of twenty-odd national orders, on the other hand, would overwhelm any single comparative argument. We will make a proposal for navigating between these two failure modes in a later post.
Aims
We pursue this comparison with three aims. First, we hope to deepen the understanding of each regional constitutionalism on its own terms. One will understand EU law’s primacy better if read through the Inter-American conventionality control and vice versa. Comparison will show them to be a contingent, explicable choice rather than a self-evident one. Comparison is, in this sense, a lens that reveals features because it supplies contrast.
Second, we hope comparison to improve the mutual understanding between two world regions that, by and large, discuss each other far less than either discusses itself, or the United States. Particularly, European constitutional scholarship rarely engages Latin American jurisprudence as a peer. Third, and most urgently, we hope it generates ideas useful in confronting the developments that now threaten the identity of both constitutionalisms, a concern we take up in a companion post on pluralism as the shared and contested core of both projects.
What Europe and Latin America Share
Why Europe and Latin America, and why now? First, both regions have developed relevant constitutional institutions at the regional level, however differently structured: the European Union on one side and the Inter-American system on the other. Both have developed regional constitutionalism, not merely regional cooperation or a preferential trade regime that leaves national sovereignty untouched. Second, both are composed of constitutional democracies that are attacked from without. In this situation, regional institutions might play a stabilizing, cushioning role that no single medium-sized state could play alone. Third, both constitutionalisms are contested from within by political forces that reject the pluralism it has come to protect, even where those forces differ sharply from one country to the next in their rhetoric, their constituencies, and their relationship to democratic legality.
A last word on symmetry, since it governs everything above and is easier to affirm than to sustain across an actual text. At no point do we treat one region as the model against which the other is measured, or as the deviation requiring explanation; this holds not only for our substantive claims but for the architecture of the comparison itself: equal depth, equal number of case studies, and an equal willingness to state where each side falls short. Difference, in our view, is not deficit. Indeed, Latin American constitutionalism succeeded in developing in a more adverse social context than the European one. If interregional comparative law is worth developing as a distinct level of comparative inquiry, alongside the comparison of states and of legal families, it will be because holding two regions up against each other, with neither serving as the template, generates insights that neither state-level nor family-level comparison could produce alone. In a companion post, we test this claim on a concrete question: what a shared but contested commitment to pluralism looks like on both sides of the Atlantic, and why the current attacks on it, though different in origin, may be more alike than they first appear.
Armin von Bogdandy is Director at the Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law.
Manuel Góngora-Mera is a Lawyer and Master of Laws in Economic Law (Pontificia Universidad Javeriana), Master in International Economics and Development Policy (Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg), and Doctor of Public Law (Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin). His career includes positions as lecturer and postdoctoral researcher at the Lateinamerika-Institut of the Freie Universität Berlin and as professor at the Universidad del Norte (Barranquilla). Visiting professor in Quito (FLACSO Ecuador) and Lima (Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú), among others.
This blog post opens the symposium Regional Constitutionalism in Latin America and Europe: Dimensions of Interregional Legal Comparison, hosted by the ICCAL Collaboration Lab on Democratic Resilience in Latin America and Europe at the Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law.
Suggested citation: Armin von Bogdandy and Manuel Góngora-Mera, ‘The Idea and Timeliness of Interregional Comparative Law between Europe and Latin America,’ IACL-AIDC Blog (19 November 2026) https://blog-iacl-aidc.org/2026-posts/2026/11/19/the-idea-and-timeliness-of-interregional-comparative-law-between-europe-and-latin-america




![Xx1088_-_Seoul_city_nightscape_during_1988_Paralympics_-_3b_-_Scan [test].jpg](https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5af3f84a4eddec846552ea29/1527486925632-3VZP3ASLAHP1LJI0D9NJ/Xx1088_-_Seoul_city_nightscape_during_1988_Paralympics_-_3b_-_Scan+%5Btest%5D.jpg)
