Varieties of Female Judicial Leadership in the Brazilian Supreme Court
/Helena Hime-Funari
Doctoral Candidate at Yale Law School (United States) and Getulio Vargas Foundation Law School (São Paulo, Brazil)
Female Chief Justices in Comparative Perspective offers several perspectives on women’s leadership in Supreme Courts. Dixon and Delaney distinguish two roles: (i) “promoting democracy and the rule of law” and/or (ii) “promoting feminist institutional and/or jurisprudential outcomes”. This distinction encompasses the “two hats” a Chief Justice must wear. The office involves not only deciding cases but also embodying the persona of Chief Justice. This role is both institutional and personal, shaped by leadership style, background and repertoire, as well as by the choices a Chief Justice makes about what is possible within the material and structural constraints she faces. Brazil has had three female Supreme Court Justices. By law, the presidency rotates by seniority to the most senior justice who has not yet served as President. All three have held the office of Chief Justice and thus headed the National Council of Justice (CNJ), the judiciary’s oversight body. To assess their leadership, I examine who they were and how their personalities shaped their choices within a judicial institution marked by significant gender inequalities.
I return to their confirmation hearings, interviews and public statements to capture how each presented herself. This offers a glimpse of complex personalities. I neither reconstruct their characters nor claim that their later approaches as Chief Justices necessarily followed from these self-presentations. My narrower aim is to add complexity to Female Chief Justices in Comparative Perspective by showing how personality, life stories and political context play a role in judicial leadership.
Justice Ellen Gracie Northfleet, the first female justice to serve on the Brazilian Supreme Court, recalled that when she arrived in 2000 she “felt at home” because Court colleagues included former professors, friends, and bosses. Her hearing was similarly reassuring. Senators recognized that nominating a woman could bring a new perspective to the Court, a position Ellen Gracie herself embraced: “I do believe there is a distinct female perspective, a complementary one, that brings a new sensitivity.” This was the tone throughout.
The confirmation hearing focused on court management and reforms to address the growing caseload, a major concern at the time. Justice Ellen Gracie discussed innovations she had introduced while serving as an appellate judge on the Federal Regional Court for the Fourth Region. This managerial approach would later mark her tenure as Chief Justice (2006-2008), when reforms included binding precedent and “general repercussion” as a certiorari-like filter for extraordinary appeals. Electronic case processing was introduced, the Court held its first public hearing, and the National Conciliation Movement was launched under the judiciary’s oversight body, which she also headed.
Justice Cármen Lúcia Antunes Rocha, the second woman appointed, joined the Court in 2006. She presented herself from a more personal perspective, emphasizing values learned at home. Her father, who began working at a young age, passed on a strong work ethic, while her mother taught her the importance of solidarity in building a country. She also stressed how judicial decisions affect people’s lives, how federalism can bring institutions closer to people’s needs, and the importance of human dignity and republicanism for state leaders.
Her presidency was marked by cases involving politicians implicated in the Operation Car Wash scandal (2016–2018), which placed the Court at the center of high-stakes politics because of its special jurisdiction over crimes involving senior public officials accused of rigging public contracts in exchange for bribes. She placed group-equality cases on the agenda, including racial quotas in public examinations (ADC 41) and transgender persons’ right to change their name and gender markers without surgery (ADI 4.275), voting in both to expand access and rights. As head of the CNJ, she promoted women’s participation in the judiciary and procedural improvements in cases of violence against women. Justice Cármen Lúcia became vocal in criticizing interruptions by male colleagues during court deliberations and in calling attention to women’s structural inequalities. On International Women’s Day, she denounced violence against women in Brazil: “It seems to be a society that has decided to kill us, but we women have decided not to let ourselves die.”
The third Justice, Rosa Maria Pires Weber, was appointed in 2011 to succeed Ellen Gracie. In her confirmation hearing, she recognized the need for social rights to bring guarantees of liberty to life, drawing on her experience at the Superior Labor Court. Her presidency (2022-2023) was marked by the January 8, 2023 attacks, when rioters invaded the Court and other government buildings. She oversaw the Court’s reconstruction and the first trials arising from the attacks. She also placed rights cases on the agenda: Indigenous land rights (RE 1.017.365), rejection of the “defense of honor” in femicide cases (ADPF 779), and abortion decriminalization up to twelve weeks (ADPF 442), in which she cast the first vote in favor as rapporteur. As head of the CNJ, Justice Weber made a gender-perspective protocol mandatory (Resolution 492) and required promotions to appellate courts to alternate between open and women-only lists until parity is reached (Resolution 525).
Justice Rosa Weber is one of the Court’s most reserved justices, having never given an interview about cases before her. Upon retiring, she told her fellow justices during a plenary session, “I shy away somewhat from the spoken word and prefer the written word.” At her last session as head of the CNJ, she added that “this more discreet profile is my way of working in what is my passion, which is case files.” Yet she reacted forcefully to the attempted coup and Court takeover in the Court’s official statements as Chief Justice: “But I warn. They did not destroy the spirit of democracy. They were not and will never be capable of subverting it, because the feeling of respect for the democratic order continues and will continue to illuminate the minds and hearts of the justices of this Supreme Court [...].”
I now go back to Dixon and Delaney’s twofold “notions of institutional feminization” as promoting both (i) the rule of law and (ii) feminist institutional and jurisprudential outcomes. One could say that Justice Ellen Gracie was vigorous in the managerial reforms of the Supreme Court, drawing on her previous experience as a judge but also on her dynamic and practical sense as a leader. In offering solutions to the Court’s large caseload, Justice Ellen Gracie advanced transparency and procedural efficiency in implementing the rule of law.
Justice Cármen Lúcia, in turn, embodied a different persona. She came after those reforms with a strong sense of social reality and justice that made her vocal in denouncing dynamics of women’s subordination. She promoted feminist institutional outcomes as a spokesperson for the Court. She was also receptive to the demands of other disadvantaged groups and placed those issues on the Court’s agenda.
Finally, Justice Rosa Weber was more restrained as a spokesperson, but extremely combative in promoting women’s rights through jurisprudential outcomes, and very conscious of how those outcomes are shaped by social reality. On the bench, she also became a voice of resistance against attacks aimed at undermining democracy. The leadership exercised by the three Brazilian Chief Justices was as diverse as their backgrounds, beliefs, and understandings of what was possible in responding to the challenges of their times. Each had a distinct personality and approach to law that shaped the way they exercised judicial leadership.
Helena Hime-Funari is a Doctoral Candidate at Yale Law School (United States) and Getulio Vargas Foundation Law School (São Paulo, Brazil)
Suggested citation: Helena Hime-Funari, ‘Varieties of Female Judicial Leadership in the Brazilian Supreme Court’, IACL-AIDC Blog (17 November 2026), https://blog-iacl-aidc.org/2026-posts/2026/11/17/varieties-of-female-judicial-leadership-in-the-brazilian-supreme-court




![Xx1088_-_Seoul_city_nightscape_during_1988_Paralympics_-_3b_-_Scan [test].jpg](https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5af3f84a4eddec846552ea29/1527486925632-3VZP3ASLAHP1LJI0D9NJ/Xx1088_-_Seoul_city_nightscape_during_1988_Paralympics_-_3b_-_Scan+%5Btest%5D.jpg)
