Constitutional Faith or Constitutional Idolatry? Insights from recent mass protests in India

Constitutional Faith or Constitutional Idolatry? Insights from recent mass protests in India

Arun THIRUVENGADAM

In his recent book, Brian Jones defines ‘constitutional idolatry’ as “drastically or persistently overselling the importance and effects of written constitutions.” Jones prefers ‘political constitutionalism’ (in which legal primacy rests in majoritarian decision-making institutions such as Parliaments) to ‘legal constitutionalism’…

Read More

Following the Constitution in Times of Corona: A Path to Redeeming Constitutional Idolatry in The Netherlands?

Following the Constitution in Times of Corona: A Path to Redeeming Constitutional Idolatry in The Netherlands?

Manon JULICHER

In his book ‘Constitutional Idolatry and Democracy’, Brian Christopher Jones describes constitutional idolatry as ‘drastically or persistently over-selling the importance and effects of written constitutions’. For a scholar trained in Dutch constitutional law this is a rather foreign concept…

Read More

The Turkish Constitution as a Disrespected Idol

The Turkish Constitution as a Disrespected Idol

Tarik OLCAY

Slinging the constitution across the table to the Prime Minister in a national security council meeting may not be the only way to trigger a national crisis, but it is one that requires the existence of a codified constitution. The ability to (literally) throw down the constitutional gauntlet might be all there is to be gained from having a codified constitution, if Brian Christopher Jones’s main argument in Constitutional Idolatry and Democracy is taken to the extreme.

Read More

The 2020 US Presidential Election: A Victory for the Democrats but a Threat to Democracy

The 2020 US Presidential Election: A Victory for the Democrats but a Threat to Democracy

Michel ROSENFELD

Viewed apart from the political crisis and ominous threat to democracy that ensued in its aftermath, the 2020 election of Joseph Biden as president of the USA ranks as routine and well within the canons of American democracy… When viewed in the context of the sequence of events that transpired from election day, 3 November 2020, until the day of final certification by the US Congress, 6 January 2021, however, the 2020 election has come uncomfortably close to culminating in an authoritarian coup.

Read More

The Anti-Mask Movement and the Rise of the Right in Ireland: What does it Mean for our Democracy?

The Anti-Mask Movement and the Rise of the Right in Ireland: What does it Mean for our Democracy?

Seána GLENNON

There have been extraordinary scenes in Dublin over the past few months, as anti-mask protests, apparently coordinated among various far right groups, have resulted in violence and arrests. At one such protest in October, Gardaí (national police) struggled to contain violent clashes between hundreds of anti-mask demonstrators and counter protesters.

Read More

Symposium: Believe in the Ideal, not the Idol: Is Constitutional Idolatry Happening in Taiwan?

Symposium: Believe in the Ideal, not the Idol: Is Constitutional Idolatry Happening in Taiwan?

Chien-Chih LIN

The supreme law in Taiwan is officially known as the Constitution of the Republic of China (ROC Constitution), which was enacted in Nanjing, China in 1947. After the establishment of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in 1949, the then ruling party, the Kuomintang Party (KMT), fled to Taiwan, with the nascent ROC Constitution in tow.

Read More

Symposium: Sweeping Away the Idols: A Review of Brian Christopher Jones’s Constitutional Idolatry and Democracy

Symposium: Sweeping Away the Idols: A Review of Brian Christopher Jones’s Constitutional Idolatry and Democracy

Sanford LEVINSON

I strongly believe the “veneration” directed at the U.S. Constitution has become almost a “clear and present danger”; it blinds Americans to the possibility that certain features of the 1787 Constitution contribute to the current dysfunctionality in the United States.

Read More

Guest Editors’ Introduction: Symposium on Constitutional Idolatry, Literacy and Identity

Guest Editors’ Introduction: Symposium on Constitutional Idolatry, Literacy and Identity

Brian Christopher JONES and Maartje DE VISSER

Contemporary constitutions not only set up the institutional infrastructure and allocate state powers; they are also expected to inspire, strengthen public confidence and trust, bring government and the people closer together, enhance citizenship, and give expression to a society’s sense of self.

Read More