Brexit and the Commonwealth: Lessons from Comparative Legal History

Brexit and the Commonwealth: Lessons from Comparative Legal History

Donal COFFEY

One troubling element of being asked to write on a topic after Asanga Welikala is the distinct possibility that he will have already thought of the best arguments, and put them forward with more elegance than one can muster. This occasion is not an exception to this rule. I want instead to draw out two elements that are present in Asanga’s text and consider them in slightly more detail.

Read More

Symposium: Federalism and Environmental Frontiers

Symposium: Federalism and Environmental Frontiers

Rebecca NELSON

Allocating and coordinating powers over parts of the environment horizontally and vertically between governments can help – or hinder – efforts to address environmental problems. As the final blogger in this series, I explain how my research addresses this issue at the intersection of two of the major lines of inquiry of the IACL Research Group on New Frontiers of Federalism…

Read More

Symposium: Institutional Design and the New Frontiers of Federalism

Symposium: Institutional Design and the New Frontiers of Federalism

Erin F. DELANEY

Comparative federalism scholars will find much to like in the remit of the newly formed IACL Research Group, “New Frontiers of Federalism.” The group’s leaders, Erika Arban and Antonia Baraggia, have outlined an ambitious set of research objectives, focusing a federal lens on some of the major challenges of our time — globalization, economic crisis, large-scale human migration, and democratic backsliding.

Read More

Symposium: Federalism & the European Union: Understanding current challenges through a federal lens

Symposium: Federalism & the European Union: Understanding current challenges through a federal lens

Matteo BONELLI

In its third line of investigation, the IACL’s Research Group on the New Frontiers of Federalism proposes to reflect, as the introduction to this symposium puts it, ‘on the role of federalism as a tool to deal with the growing complexity of a multilevel constitutional space’. The European Union, a multilevel constitutional space par excellence, seems an excellent case study for this area of research.

Read More

Symposium: Using Constitutional Controversies to Protect Human Rights

Symposium: Using Constitutional Controversies to Protect Human Rights

Roberto NIEMBRO

One of the focal points of the IACL research group ‘New Frontiers of Federalism’ is the role of local governments as new key players in the management of public services and the protection of rights. This exploration line centers on the analysis of metropolitan cities, as unique socio-economic and political spaces in contemporary times…

Read More

Symposium: Quasi-Federalism and Localism: The Constitutional Position of Local Government in the UK

Symposium: Quasi-Federalism and Localism: The Constitutional Position of Local Government in the UK

John STANTON

The newly formed IACL Research Group on “New Frontiers of Federalism”, of which I am a member, “aims at exploring a number of emerging issues in classic federal theory and practice” … My academic expertise lies in the area of UK Constitutional Law, with a particular focus on localism and devolution.

Read More

What Kind of Judge are You?

What Kind of Judge are You?

Pedro Felipe DE OLIVEIRA SANTOS

Working both in academia and the judiciary, I have been asked by students and colleagues whether I am an originalist, a textualist, a pragmatist, or a living constitutionalist judge. This question intrigues me. Why should I choose just one interpretative methodology? Across the world, constitutional scholars and judges have become partisan, as if accounts of constitutional interpretation were mutually exclusive.

Read More

Is the Dissolution of the Peruvian Congress a Constitutional Measure?

Is the Dissolution of the Peruvian Congress a Constitutional Measure?

César LANDA ARROYO

On 30 September 2019, the parliamentary majority bloc called a vote on the appointment of six new judges to the Constitutional Court of Peru. Candidates were selected from a list of eleven attorneys who the Special Commission of Unicameral Congress had invited to participate, based on its partisan interests. Just days before, the Prime Minister had asked Congress for a vote of confidence…

Read More

Symposium: The Federal Council: The Secret to the Institutional Success of the German Federal System

Symposium: The Federal Council: The Secret to the Institutional Success of the German Federal System

Jens WOELK

German federalism is different from “dual” federal systems, such as the United States of America, characterised by parallel federal and state structures. By contrast, in Germany the federal administration is not fully developed: the Länder take care of the implementation of federal legislation as well as of their own in order to avoid costly and inefficient duplication.

Read More

Symposium: More Than Just Rights – The Basic Law and Its Fundamental Rights Chapter

Symposium: More Than Just Rights – The Basic Law and Its Fundamental Rights Chapter

Michael GOLDHAMMER

With the enactment of the Basic Law, some of the central debates relating to Weimar Constitutional Law came to an end: the range of emergency competences of the Reichspresident became just as obsolete as the discussions about constitutional amendments and other problems. It is different with fundamental rights, though.

Read More

The Supreme Court ruling: why the effects test could help save democracy (somewhat)

The Supreme Court ruling: why the effects test could help save democracy (somewhat)

Tarun KHAITAN

It is hard to overestimate the political as well as the legal implications of today’s ground-breaking Supreme Court ruling, writes Tarun Khaitan (University of Oxford). It applied an effects-based test to the case rather than trying to establish the purpose of Boris Johnson’s move to prorogue Parliament. In doing so it created a brand new and sophisticated ammunition in the rapidly ageing arsenal of democracy defenders.

Read More

Symposium: The Financial Constitution of the Basic Law

Symposium: The Financial Constitution of the Basic Law

Gregor KIRCHHOF

There can be no functioning state without money. Finances enable policy-makers to act. The constitutional rules governing finances – the financial constitution – therefore determine an essential power factor, and in this respect bring about a highly-distinctive separation of powers between the Federation, the Länder and municipalities.

Read More